This post contains affiliate links . translate full disclosure statement here .
While diatomaceous worldly concern ( DE ) is often recommended as pesticide , there are problems . It ’s non - selective ( ca n’t tell pollinator from pest ) , ineffective when wet , and the okay particles harm mammals .
If you want to cognize more debunked garden tips also seePopular Garden Myths We ’ve All lessen For .
My Garden
The Pros and Cons of Diatomaceous Earth
If you ’ve been here before you have sex I never use pesticide , herbicide , insecticide , or any other treatments in our garden , and , besides some hired man - picking of specific vegetable - chomping bug , I opt to leave everything to sort itself out .
But I am always interested in learning about possible organic solvent to common garden job .
Over the years I have becomea pollinator - centric gardenerfocusing on the health of my localeco - systemand that is the core of my garden decision making .
For every action I involve , will this supporter or wound the pollinator ? Is this necessary ? What will happen if I bequeath the job to solve itself ? And could the solution cause other harm ?
It makes a mess of garden decisions really easy .
And , unfortunately , diatomaceous earth(DE ) , while classified as an organic solution — because it comes from fossilized specie of single - celled algae — it has some drawbacks which neither help the pollinators , or other animals including darling , nor make it a pragmatic choice .
Contents
What is Diatomaceous Earth?
Diatomaceous dry land ( DE ) is form from fossilised species of single - celled algae called diatom .
In pulverization form , it is a milky - white color and somewhat downy like slightly moist baking flour . It looks soft but , when viewed under a microscope , it is really tiny sherd of glass - like pieces . You may also hear DE referred to as “ silica dust . ”
From the “ world ” name , you might recollect DE is a eccentric of soil , butdiatomaceousmeans it is formed fromdiatoms — which produce about a quarter of the cosmos ’s oxygen .
Diatomsare microscopic , individual - celled algae , so they hold out in water , usually near the surface where they use sunlight for photosynthesis .
There are ( at least ) ten of thousands of dissimilar metal money of diatoms and they take in a lot of silica which we know as the primary component of sand and shabu . This is an of import point as you ’ll see below .
diatom finally die and fossilize and trillions of them compile over the 100 and millenary to form diatomaceous earth . The DE we reap is on land where waterways once existed .
This part sound fine but keep reading to see how it is used and why it can be a problem — especially if a human or pet inhales it .
Why Diatomaceous Earth is Used as a Pesticide
Ground into a white or more or less off - white powder , diatomaceous land is somewhat subdued to the touch for humans . But these lilliputian particles ( half the breadth of human hair ) are troublesome for unsuspecting insects that play them .
At a microscopic story , you’re able to see the silicon oxide in the diatom are like knifelike minuscule pieces of deoxyephedrine .
And it ’s not just the jagged edges that are the problem .
The atom also stick to the insect ’s dead body and absorb wax from their KO’d protective layer — which is no longer so protective without the wax .
This do some dirt ball to lose water , dry up and sometimes die . Others may be able-bodied to withstand it .
slug and snailswill forefend diatomaceous earth as well , although how often it in reality kills them seems to be a subject of argumentation . Andforget that advice to use chop eggshellsto thwart those slimy creatures : enquiry shows they just glide right over them .
So , it can do what it suppose . But , keep reading .
concern : deal With Slugs & Snails Without harm Your Garden
Organic Does Not Mean Harmless
Why Diatomaceous Earth Gets Recommended
1 ) First , it ’s made from of course pass off stuff , so it does check theorganicbox . Butjust because something is “ organic ” does not mean it is of necessity good or safe .
2 ) And it ’s thephysical — not chemical — properties of the particles that make it a pesticide — literally rubbing insects the wrong way of life — which is also authoritative to many earth - friendly gardeners .
This physical affect also mean the insects are not going to build physiologic immunity or electric resistance to it as they would with chemical pesticide .
3 ) “ intellectual nourishment grade ” diatomaceous earthly concern isnot toxic ( when ingested ) to mammalsincluding man but you still take to be cautious .
You do not need to get it in youreyesor yourlungswhere those o.k. , crank - comparable speck will be a problem — so masks and goggles are commend when apply it .
Same trouble when diatomaceous earth is used to handle fleas on pets like cats and dogs : those fine , sharp particle can be unsafe for their respiratory systems too . We ’re all mammal !
The Problem with Diatomaceous Earth as a Pesticide
It ’s overseas - spectrum pesticide , meaning , it does not single out between plague and good louse . regretful , pollinators !
Most insect do n’t do any hurt in your garden and do a mess of good ( many ‘ pests ’ are lunch for beneficial insects ) , but diatomaceous earth is n’t become to mark off if they ’re spicy or overnice first .
And — this is a immense drawback — it does n’t work when it gets soaked .
Just the moisture in your soil will cut down its effectiveness , and if it rain down , or you water your soil — forget about it : you ’re go to have to reapply it every time .
Have I lost you yet ?
Well , how about this : when juiceless , the current of air can blow it away . Good - bye , money .
So , not very naturalistic for the median nurseryman : the lotion is impractical and the issue are imprecise .
I realize some will say , so what ’s a few deadened bug if I manage to get rid of the trouble ones ?
First , I ’d ask , does it really solve it ?
These things seldom subsist in isolation .
And secondly , it ’s up to you , of course . I just stick to prioritizing the beneficial insects including pollinators which in turn help that heavy old rophy of living do its thing . pestilence will always occur and go and are an essential part of the food chain .
Given that diatomaceous earthly concern is light enough to be taken by the wind when dry and rendered useless when wet , it does not seem like a realistic solution for most gardeners yet you will hear diatomaceous earth recommended — ostensibly with little or no thought about the practical app .
The Earth of gardening is fill with this character of advice : on the face of it ready to hand soundbites that confound the gardener trying to succeed them .
Rodale ’s Organic Gardener ’s Handbook of Natural Pest and Disease Controldoes monish thatDE is as lethal to good louse as it is to pestsand says it should only be used as a last resort .
And that ’s the problem we have with pesticide in general : if they do study , they take the barren bystander down too including any salutary bugs that go on to be in its path .
Is Diatomaceous Earth Sustainable?
There ’s also the question of sustainability — and that ’s an progeny where it ’s always operose to get a consecutive , indifferent result .
I could n’t retrieve one , so I ’ll just kindle it as a inquiry :
Diatomaceous dry land has build up up over 1000000 of years and we mine it or collect it in big batches .
Can this eccentric of mining ever be sustainable ?
It sound a lot like harvesting peat from peat bog which is also problematical .
I ’ve seen peat brag as a renewable resource but , when you curb the fact , it ‘ renews ’ at a pace of just millimetres every thousand years . So who are we kidding ? I guess a lot of things could be considered renewable if there ’s no metre limit on their renewal .
Yes , there ’s no dearth of silica on earth and we have plenty of diatomaceous globe , but we have plenty of peat in some parts of the world too .
Besides taking meg of years to form , it ’s the process of harvesting , machinate , sacking , and disperse these things may quickly delete any quick fuzzed tactual sensation ‘ constituent ’ and ‘ natural ’ bring . And the decimate land left behind is a whole other eco - disaster .
Related : How the Term “ Organic ” Misleads Gardeners
This topic is a undecomposed lesson in looking beyond the experience - skilful recording label and considering the bigger picture .
So , no dematiaceous land forour eco - beneficial garden .
And , in suit you ’re enquire , am I able-bodied to adhere to my environmentally - friendly saint as a nurseryman ?
Hardly .
The garden world is filled with un - fleeceable product and pattern . It ’s easy to avoid weedkiller , pesticide , and man-made fertilizers , but the gardening humankind is horribly interconnect with individual - use charge plate and loads of other unsuitable thing .
But I hope by call into question stuff like this we aim ourselves in a good focusing . One bee at a time .
Listen
~Melissathe Empress of Dirt ♛
Special Offer
Empress of DirtGarden Goodies Digital Bundle
8 Ebooks & Printable Garden Planner & Moreby Melissa J. Will ~ Empress of Dirt
All Empress of Dirt fan - favorite garden - related digital products together — at last !
See inclination of everything included here|Visit Ebook Shop
These items are digital data file ( PDF data formatting ) you save to your twist , not physical product .
PayPal , Credit Card , Apple Pay
