The resolution is different if you ’ve stocked up on rude or conventional PB …

Getty Images / AtlasStudio

Peanut butter is part of the starting batting order of thepantry stapleessentials in our Test Kitchen and nearly everyBHGeditor ’s home .

jar of peanut butter spread

Credit:Getty Images / AtlasStudio

Although we light in love with it as kiddos as part of PB&Js ( sans - crust at the time , of course ) , we ’ve grown to adore featuring peanut butter in both scented and savoury lulu . A spoonful is all it takes to transmute a pipe bowl of morningoatsorquinoafrom boring to daytime - brightening . We also rely on it often to star incookies , Reese ’s copycat cups , cozypeanut lather , and beyond .

It ’s exonerated we ’re not alone in our latria of all things peanut butter : About 94 % of all American menage have at least one jarful of peanut butter on - hand , concord to theNational Peanut Board .

A jar of goober butter — or an allergen - free alternative — is almost a ubiquitous part of American sprightliness . But unless you know how to store peanut butter sagely , you might be causing it to spoil faster . ( Yes , peanut butter can go big ! )

How to Store Peanut Butter

“ The enemies of most larder food are unaccented , oxygen , heat , and moisture , and peanut butter is no dissimilar , ” explain Erin Alderson , the Sacramento , California - base creator of and formula developer for Naturally Ella and author of approaching cookbookThe Yearlong Pantry . “ The oils that make peanut butter so creamy and scrumptious are also what change to make it sample ‘ off ’ over fourth dimension , ” so keep those as fresh as potential is the goal as you master how to store peanut butter .

The ideal method for how to hive away groundnut butter deviate establish on the type .

Conventional Peanut Butter

Theheart - healthyoils in nut butter are great for humans , but posture a challenge for long - condition storage since these unsaturated fats tend to fall apart down more quickly , Alderson explains : “ The mellow the amount of unsaturated fat in a food , the greater the risk of rancidity . This is why conventional peanut butter often uses hydrogenated crude oil like palm tree . These oil are higher in saturated fatness , which are more shelf - stable . ”

Store unopenedandopened conventional groundnut butter with the lid securely twisted on in a cool , teetotal position like your buttery or a kitchen cupboard out from heat and easy beginning , suggests Meggan Hill , the Valencia , California - based executive chef and CEO of Culinary Hill .

“ The preservative and ledge - stabilizers in ceremonious peanut butter have in mind that it can be safely stored after opening for 2 to 3 months , ” Hill says .

To extend the ledge life-time of capable ceremonious peanut butter , store it in the refrigerator for 6 to 9 months , Alderson and Hill agree . That being said , “ it ’s formulated to be shelf unchanging for a foresighted period of clock time , so a icebox is rarely involve , ” Alderson tote up , unless you seldom , if ever , rust or bake with your nut butter .

Natural Peanut Butter

As for natural peanut butter , which has fewer additives , “ the potential for libertine rancidity is real because instinctive and freshly ground peanut butter only trust on natural peanut fossil oil , ” Alderson says , rather than palm oil color or other more saturated oils that support shelf - stability .

All - lifelike groundnut butters can go rancid within weeks at way temporary , Hill says , so store unopened natural peanut vine butter in the refrigerator ( at 42 ° F or lower ) for up to 6 months . Once opened , keep instinctive earthnut butter with its chapeau securely twist on in the icebox for 1 to 2 months . Some brand might last longer , so check the recording label for specific instructions .

“ Since all - natural groundnut butters often have crude oil separation , it ’s great to stir them after possibility and before refrigerate . The infrigidation should help prevent natural goober pea butter from separate again , ” Hill says .

What About Other Nut and Seed Butters?

These guidelines utilize to all en and ejaculate butters , our expert confirm .

“ Products made with ledge - stabilizer [ this includes Nutella ] are ok in the pantry for 2 to 3 months after hatchway , while all - lifelike versions should be stored in the icebox so they do n’t go rancid , ” Hill says .

How Long Does Peanut Butter Last?

TheUSDAconfirms that established peanut vine butter can be hive away in a coolheaded , juiceless place like your buttery for 6 to 9 months ( unopened ) or 2 to 3 month ( after chess opening ) . If you refrigerate ceremonious peanut vine butter after gap , it should be safe for 6 to 9 month .

All - natural groundnut butter can be refrigerated for up to 6 calendar month unopened . After the seal has been broken , it ’s best enjoy within 1 to 2 month after opening , with refrigerator computer storage , unless the label tell otherwise .

Can You Freeze Peanut Butter?

Here ’s some welcome news for those who love tobuy in majority : “ Any goober butter can be frozen for up to a twelvemonth , ” Hill says .

Store your instinctive or formal peanut butter in its plastic shock or transfer it to an airtight container . apply a marker to label with the date , then thawing overnight at room temperature or in the refrigerator .

Can Peanut Butter Go Bad?

It sure can , and this all churn down to the oil . Once it goes rancid , your paste will be noticeably " off . "

“ you could tell peanut butter has queer by both its appearance and odor , ” Hill says .

The stick to are sign that your peanut butter isstale or spoiled :

Both Alderson and Hill admit that they have no difficulty making it through their shock of peanut butter in plenty of time before it goes bad , though , since they reach for it almost daily . J. J. Hill likes to start her Clarence Shepard Day Jr. with aPeanut Butter Smoothie , is honeyed on a collation of orchard apple tree slice with peanut butter , and swears by a grill peanut butter and strawberry jelly sandwich for dejeuner . As for Alderson , she keeps her jar handy forPeanut Sauce(to moisten over attic pipe bowl , roast sweet potatoes , and beyond ) andPeanut Butter Buckeye Balls with Popped Quinoa .