Are Hostas the Plastic Swans of Plants?

The thought of putting white charge plate swan planter in my garden leave me goose bumps . And not in a good manner .

I ’m not a garden snob . take in a rogue garden gnome here or there gives me heavy joy . But a landscape painting filled with a caboodle of shaping inanimate objects just seems obstinate to garden as a conception . After all , our avocation or vocation is the art of subtly bending living thing found in the rude universe into esthetically pleasing scenes . If you plop a bunch of obviously man - made item all over the space , it ’s jarring . Or at least that ’s how I feel when I accede a space fulfil with more plastic pinwheel than plant .

I do n’t feel that manner about myhostas , though . They are living plants , not something manufacture in a poly - rosin factory somewhere . But after reading theinterview with Doug Tallamyinissue # 208 , I might necessitate to rethink my hostas .

If you ’re attuned to the earthly concern of horticulture , you have no doubt read one of Dr. Tallamy ’s books , look a conference where he has been a verbaliser , or perhaps even participated as a educatee in one of his biodiversity social class . His work advocate for the conservation of native ecosystems , something most gardeners wholeheartedly support . But as a nurseryman , I have to ask : Are the nonnative flora in my landscape ruining the local ecosystem ? Is my ‘ Island Breeze ’ hosta an environmental fortune ? perchance .

As Tallamy get wind it , my hosta is just sit down there , not doing any harm , but not doing good either . It ’s an ecological blank - makeweight . But if I planted , say , an oak tree diagram , I ’d be helping provender and shelter roughly 952 creatures . “ guess of your hosta as a trivial plastic statue . It ’s there , and it ’s not wrecking anything ; it ’s just not help anything , ” Tallamy says .

That last piece reach me hard . If I would n’t dare fill my landscape with shaping swan , why would I fill it with the plant tantamount ? What I have a go at it most about the interview with Tallamy was how he speak flat to gardeners ’ concerns and how we might hit a rest between the slyness we eff and the planet we care for . It ’s not about found onlynative plant , but more about the damage that have zero aboriginal plants can do .

And it ’s about saying no to moldable swans , regardless .

— Danielle Sherry , executive editor,[email protect ]

See more fromFine Gardening#208

all right Gardening advocate Products

The Nature of oak : The Rich Ecology of Our Most Essential Native Trees

okay Gardening receives a commission for particular purchased through links on this website , admit Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertizement programs .

set in a Post - Wild World : Designing Plant Communities for Resilient Landscapes

ARS Telescoping Long Reach Pruner

Get our former peak , how - to articles , and instructional video sent to your inbox .

Signing you up …

Join Fine Gardening for a free engaging live webinar featuring Dr. Janna Beckerman , a famous works diagnostician as well as prof emerita at Purdue University and the ornamentals expert manager …

When I spotted a particular sand clam cactus ( Astrophytum asterias ) at the Philadelphia Flower Show a few month ago , I knew I was in trouble . With a delightful color pattern …

When we only prioritise plant life we desire over plants our landscape painting needs , each time of year is filled with a never - ending lean of chores : pruning , pinching , lacrimation , treating , amending , and fertilizing , with …

Video

Touring an Eco-friendly, Shady Backyard Retreat

You must be careful when you enter the backyard of garden decorator Jeff Epping — not because you ’re likely to trip on something , but because you might be dive - bombed by a pair …